Home › Guides › Motors and drives
Motor Starters Compared: DOL, Star-Delta, Soft Starter and VFD

- DOL: small motors, high inrush
- Star-delta: about 1/3 starting current
- Soft starter: smooth ramp
- VFD: smoothest + speed control
On this page
Why Starting Method Matters
When an AC motor starts, it draws a large inrush current. On a weak supply or a generator, this dips voltage for everything else, trips breakers and stresses the motor, couplings and pipes (water hammer in pumps). The starter you choose controls that first few seconds.
The Four Options Compared
| DOL | Star-delta | Soft starter | VFD | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting current | High (about 6–8 × FLA) | About 1/3 of DOL | Adjustable, reduced | Lowest, near rated current |
| Starting torque | Full | About 1/3 of DOL | Reduced, adjustable | Controlled, high at low speed |
| Speed control | No | No | No | Yes |
| Cost | Lowest | Low–medium | Medium | Highest |
| Typical use | Small motors | Medium motors, light start (pumps, fans) | Pumps, compressors, conveyors | Variable demand, energy saving |
How a Star-Delta Starter Works
- The main contactor and the star contactor close: the windings are connected in star, so each sees reduced voltage.
- The motor accelerates for a few seconds, set on a timer.
- The star contactor opens and the delta contactor closes: the motor now runs at full voltage.
- An overload relay protects against sustained over-current.
The motor must be rated for delta at your supply voltage (for example 415 V delta) and have six terminals brought out. Star-delta suits loads that start light, like centrifugal pumps and fans; heavy-start loads may stall in star.
Safety: motor starters, drives, cables, breakers and three-phase connections must be designed, installed and tested by a qualified electrician. Isolate and lock off power before touching any terminal. These figures help you plan and ask the right questions.
Which Starter Should You Use?
- Small single-phase or three-phase motors on a strong supply: DOL.
- Medium three-phase pumps and fans with light starting load: star-delta or a soft starter.
- Pumps where water hammer is a problem: a soft starter with soft stop, or a VFD.
- Demand that varies through the day (booster sets, fans): a VFD.
- Running from a generator: reduce inrush with a soft starter or VFD so the generator can be smaller.
Motors at H-TECH
POWER-UK ELECTRIC MOTOR 2HP (High speed)KSh 21,000
POWER-UK ELECTRIC MOTOR 3HP (High speed)KSh 24,000
POWER-UK ELECTRIC MOTOR 7.5HP (High speed)KSh 39,000
POWER-UK ELECTRIC MOTOR 10HP (Low speed)KSh 45,000| Product | Price |
|---|---|
| POWER-UK ELECTRIC MOTOR 2HP (High speed) | KSh 21,000 |
| POWER-UK ELECTRIC MOTOR 3HP (High speed) | KSh 24,000 |
| POWER-UK ELECTRIC MOTOR 7.5HP (High speed) | KSh 39,000 |
| POWER-UK ELECTRIC MOTOR 10HP (Low speed) | KSh 45,000 |
Current listed prices incl. VAT (updated 18 November 2026).
Speed control in depth: VFD guide. Motor basics: single-phase vs three-phase motors.
Testing and Common Faults
| Symptom | Check |
|---|---|
| Motor hums in star, will not speed up | Load too heavy for star start; low voltage; one phase missing |
| Trips on changeover to delta | Timer too short; wrong wiring sequence |
| Overload trips after running | Overload set wrong; motor overloaded; voltage imbalance |
| Contactor chatter | Low control voltage; worn coil |
Mistakes to Avoid
- Star-delta on a motor not rated for delta at 415 V.
- Timer set too long or too short.
- Overload relay set to the wrong current.
- DOL on a big motor fed from a generator.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between DOL and star-delta?
DOL connects full voltage at once with high starting current; star-delta starts in star at reduced voltage (about a third of the current) and then switches to delta.
Which is better, soft starter or star-delta?
A soft starter gives a smoother, adjustable start and soft stop; star-delta is cheaper but has a current spike at changeover.
Is a VFD better than a soft starter?
A VFD also controls speed and saves energy on pumps and fans; a soft starter only controls starting and stopping.
What size motor needs a star-delta starter?
It depends on the supply and the utility’s rules; medium three-phase motors with light starting loads are typical candidates.
How do I test a star-delta starter with a multimeter?
With power isolated, check contactor coils and contacts for continuity and the motor windings for balanced resistance; live tests should be done by an electrician.
